|
Meet the Measles
By Abe Greenwald
For a supposedly authoritarian president, Donald Trump has put up with a lot of dissent in his administration. In fact, he’s tolerated more internal dissent than most men who’ve held the office. Since the midterms, Vice President JD Vance has, after all, become a public malcontent set on blaming the historic Republican losses on Trump’s decision to go to war in Iran.
But Trump has finally decided to deal with his Vance problem. He’s sidelined Vance, who prolonged the war with a poorly considered peace memorandum, and has taken him off the Iran file entirely.
That still leaves the president with Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. RFK Jr. is not usually considered a Trump dissenter, but he should be. And his particular dissenting opinion has had devastating consequences.
It’s no secret that Kennedy has been an outspoken critic of the mRNA vaccine that Trump’s Operation Warp Speed produced during the Covid pandemic. In 2024, he described Operation Warp Speed as “the most devastating impact of President Trump’s weakness, but not the only one.” The idea being that Trump was too cowardly to resist the corporate interests that wanted to sell the vaccine as soon as possible.
Of course, Kennedy, unlike Vance, is more than a little strange. And as HHS secretary, he’s pushed for policies such as limiting vaccinations for various diseases, removing longstanding recommendations for flu and other vaccines, and slowing the vaccine research process. He hasn’t been thoroughly successful, and the courts have shot him down numerous times. But in terms of spreading the antivax gospel, his term has been a tour de force.
Kennedy took the hippie-dippie, “nature heals” anti-science theology of his native left and married it to the post-Covid anti-vaccine fixation on the populist right. He officially revived the nonsense argument linking vaccines to autism and fed vaccine-phobia into our thriving conspiracy-theory economy. Since Kennedy was confirmed, certain vaccination numbers have reached stunning national milestones—not good ones. In the 2025–26 school year, kindergartner exemptions (mostly nonmedical) from routine vaccines hit 4.2 percent, a record high. During the previous year, exemptions were at 3.6 percent, and before that, 2.2 percent. “The share of kindergartners who received MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccines,” notes the Wall Street Journal, “slipped to 92.4% last year from 95.2% in 2019.”
So here we are. As of yesterday, the U.S.’s “measles elimination” status has been revoked by the Pan American Health Organization. Not knowing much about this organization and being generally skeptical of international bodies, I was reluctant to take this pronouncement as dispositive. But then I looked at the numbers. Again, from the Journal: “More than 5,400 cases have been reported this year, the most since 1991. Between 2000 and 2024, cases averaged about 180 a year.” Additionally, 10 percent of these cases led to hospitalization, and more than 1 percent resulted in death.
Questioned about the measles outbreak earlier this year, Kennedy said, “It’s not unusual” and “We have measles outbreaks every year.” A few months later, he complained, “Every child who gets measles gets a headline.”
But conspiracy theories don’t merely make you dumber—they kill. And it’s conspiracy theories and pseudoscience that have made RFK Jr. the HHS secretary who brought back measles. Which makes Trump the president who brought back measles. Which means Trump now has an RFK Jr. problem to deal with.
Abe Greenwald is the executive editor of COMMENTARY. |